Donald Trump struggles with Jewish voters despite pro-Israel record


His file on Israel is so robust that radio host Mark Levin as soon as referred to as him “the primary Jewish president,” however President Trump has but to really feel the love from the Jewish voters.

A Pew Analysis Heart ballot launched this week confirmed that 70% of registered Jewish voters help Democratic presidential candidate Joseph R. Biden over Mr. Trump, who was the selection of 27% — barely greater than the 24% who backed him in 2016.

That hardly perceptible transfer of the needle comes even because the Democratic Social gathering’s progressive wing continues to development away from Israel and towards Palestinian causes, led by rising stars similar to Reps. Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, whereas Mr. Trump has repeatedly aligned himself with Jerusalem.

So far as Jewish Republicans are involved, it shouldn’t be a detailed name. “President Trump has been probably the most pro-Jewish president in historical past,” mentioned Neil Strauss, communications director of the Republican Jewish Coalition.

Actually, Mr. Trump seems to be much more well-liked with the Jewish group in Israel than he’s at house. A Direct Polls/i24 survey launched Monday discovered 63% of Israelis believed Mr. Trump can be “higher for Israel,” versus 19% for Mr. Biden.

As well as, 53% mentioned that they thought Israel can be “considerably harmed” if Mr. Trump misplaced the Nov. three election. What’s extra, 48% of Israelis mentioned American Jews had been “mistaken” in backing the Democratic Social gathering, whereas 35% mentioned they had been “right.”

“Their [Jewish voters’] concerns when going to vote will not be simply Israel,” Dani Dayan, former counsul basic of Israel in New York, advised i24. “I would love very a lot if they might allocate to the Israel problem a a lot greater weight than they do, however there are different points that concern them.”

Certainly, conservatives have lengthy banged their collective heads in frustration over the Jewish voting bloc’s unwavering help for the Democratic Social gathering, which seems to bear little relation to both occasion’s file on Israel.

“Why American Jews persistently help Democrats has been one of many mysteries of the many years,” mentioned Cornell Regulation Faculty professor William Jacobson, who runs the Authorized Rebellion web site. “For so long as I can bear in mind, liberalism has been the predominant political ideology of American Jews, notably within the Reform Jewish motion, the most important group inside the American Jewish group.”

He mentioned these demographics are altering as the proportion of U.S. Orthodox Jews rises, “however the change has not taken place but.”

“I don’t suppose it revolves round help for or hostility in direction of Israel,” Mr. Jacobson mentioned. “Apart from far-left teams that obtain plenty of media consideration, the overwhelming majority of American Jews help Israel no matter political affiliation.”

Logan Bayroff, communications director of the liberal Jewish group J Avenue, referred to as it “under no circumstances stunning that polls point out the overwhelming majority of American Jews plan to vote towards Donald Trump.”

“Each election for many years has demonstrated that almost all American Jews are dependable Democratic voters motivated primarily by liberal values and home issues,” Mr. Bayroff mentioned in an electronic mail.

On the similar time, Mr. Strauss mentioned no one must be stunned by Mr. Trump’s help amongst Israelis, who “know who will stand with them and the Gulf States towards Iran, ISIS, and different radical Islamic terrorist organizations.”

“To Israelis, that is an existential problem,” he mentioned, “they usually know who will get up of Israeli security and safety.”

Jewish grandchildren

Mr. Trump’s record of pro-Israel insurance policies begin with the exit from the Iran nuclear deal, an Obama White Home settlement that was fiercely opposed by Israel and even some Jewish Democratic lawmakers. Mr. Biden has mentioned he would reenter the deal if Tehran “returns to compliance.”

Mr. Trump’s different milestones embody recognizing Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights and relocating the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, a transfer that presidents had lengthy averted over concern of inflaming tensions within the Arab world.

“The Trump administration really has executed one thing of nice symbolic and substantive impact — moved the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem and acknowledged Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, a transfer promised by earlier presidents as candidates however not carried out by them as soon as in workplace,” mentioned Eric Rozenman, previously of the Jewish Coverage Heart.

The Trump administration additionally withheld funding to the Palestinian Authority within the West Financial institution and Gaza over terrorism issues. Home and Senate Democrats urged the administration earlier this yr to renew assist, citing the coronavirus pandemic.

Mr. Rozenman described it as a far cry from President Barack Obama’s arms-length relationship with Israel.

“[M]any Israelis throughout the political spectrum recall the Obama administration’s public coverage of ‘placing distance’ between the US and Israel, on the idea this could one way or the other make Washington a extra enticing diplomatic accomplice to some Arab international locations or the Palestinian Arabs,” he mentioned, “after which Vice President Biden’s function in delivering unpalatable messages to Jerusalem.”

At house, Mr. Trump signed in December an government order cracking down on campuses that adopted the definition of anti-Semitism utilized by the Worldwide Holocaust Remembrance Alliance.

Final week, the Trump Schooling Division settled a criticism introduced by a Jewish scholar through which New York College agreed to take steps to ameliorate anti-Semitism, together with including it to the college’s non-discrimination and anti-harassment coverage whereas admitting no wrongdoing.

J Avenue was not impressed. “In the case of the president’s Israel insurance policies, most of our group acknowledges that they’ve solely exacerbated the Israeli-Palestinian battle and made a peaceable two-state answer tougher to realize,” Mr. Bayroff mentioned.

Then there are Mr. Trump’s Jewish household ties. His daughter Ivanka, who transformed to Judaism when she married, and son-in-law Jared Kushner are acknowledged as the primary Jewish members of a primary household. They’ve three youngsters, which means the president has three Jewish grandchildren.

None of that has been sufficient to inoculate Mr. Trump from allegations of anti-Semitism. A Washington Submit report final month accused him of claiming Jews are “solely in it for themselves” and “stick collectively,” citing unnamed present and former administration officers, which the White Home staunchly disputed.

Mr. Trump’s critics even have accused him of supporting “white nationalism” and white supremacy, which he denies, however his “assaults on democratic norms and his belligerent, reckless international coverage are all abhorrent and alarming to Jewish voters,” mentioned Mr. Bayroff.

Mr. Strauss disagreed, saying that Mr. Trump “has repeatedly condemned anti-Semitism on the appropriate and the left.”

Join Every day Newsletters


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here